The Freight Forwarders' Association of India had invited me to speak to them at their annual convention in Goa in Jule 2009. The association consists essentially of small and medium sized family run businesses and they wanted to hear whether branding is a worthwhile and feasible option for them. I am hoping that you will find it useful too.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Is Branding a
good strategy for
your business ?
Is
it correct for
me to speak
to an audience
of Freight Forwarding
companies about branding?
If you are
like most people
I know of,
I am sure
you cannot conceive of branding
without advertising. I
am sure you
would automatically assume
that branding is an appropriate
activity for a consumer product company but not necessarily for an industrial
service company like
yours. If so, be
prepared for this fact : out of the top 5 brands on earth, 4 are industrial brands and only one is a
consumer brand. The figures
in brackets indicate
the brand valuation in 2003
- Coca
Cola ( Rs 340,000 Crores )
- Microsoft
( Rs 300,000 Crores )
- IBM
( Rs 260,000 Crores )
- GE
( Rs 240,000 Crores )
- Intel
( Rs 180,000 Crores )
You
do not necessarily need
to advertise to build your brand
It is
clear that these 4 industrial brands
have become valuable
by doing much more
than mere advertising. Advertising and branding are
different. Advertising may be pretty and
attractive but it is more like the superficial clothes. Brand
is more like
the person inside
the clothes. For the advertising to
work, who you are, and what you do, must
be worthy of
advertising in the
first place! Creating a
brand is not about spending on advertising but about 3 things
- attracting
customers by offering a unique value to them
- getting a better price out of
them than your competitors
- creating a stronger platform for your future growth.
Anyone who is advertising but not achieving
these three things is only advertising but not building a brand. On the other hand, anyone who is
achieving this is building a brand - and it does not matter whether he is advertising or not. The proof of branding is happy and loyal customers and not whether you are advertising.
How a good brand will pay for itself
Following 6 benefits of branding will add up to at least 10% - 15% of your Profit and Loss statement every year. Hence it is worthwhile to spend money to build a brand for yourself. Please realize I am not saying you need to spend money on advertising to build your brand ! It is possible that you are spending money on advertising and yet none of these 6 benefits are coming to you. If so, you are not building a brand even if you are spending a lot in advertising.
- New
business : You get more calls when new
business comes along.
- Prices
: Your charging becomes
the norm and others
face price comparison with you
- Margins
: are higher because your quotes
are doubted and
compared less
- Suppliers
: more keen to deal with you – even if
your pricing is slightly unfavourable
- Investors
are
keen to invest
in your business
- Talented employees are
keen to get
experience and make
a career with
you
I do not
know about you but, to me, these 6 benefits will add up to a benefit that is at least 10% - 15% of
sales revenue. That is a pretty tidy figure for anyone! And, apart from these regular day to day benefits, you have to remember that there are 2 other benefits of branding you will get :
- BRANDING APPRECIATES
WITH TIME :
physical assets like buildings, furniture and vehicles depreciate with time but branding is exactly the opposite. It gets
more polished and more valuable with use.
- BRAND BRINGS GOOD PRICE WHEN SOLD : shares of
branded companies are sold
at higher P/E multiples. With
your sales and
profits of your
business remaining the
same, your business
will get much
more valuation if
you are in
possession of the brand. In fact they say that if Coke brand is
sold, the buyer will not like to buy the physical assets of Coke like factories
and buildings etc because 95% of the value of Coke brand is not in the physical
assets. Where does the value of the brand lie then? It lies in the favorable
opinion billions of people all over the world has of Coke!
2 tests of a superior brand
The first test of a superior brand is the trust
of “its customers” .
The second test is
that such customers must believe that the brand is better than its competitors.
It is not
necessary for a “superior brand” to be known by everybody! However "its customers” (we call them target customers in marketing) must know it well, trust it and believe that
it is different and better than its competitors. Let us take some examples of such brands. The chances are you may not have heard of them but yet they are very strong brands among "its customers"
- Biogel is recognised
brand in surgical glove business
- Bill Shiner is a top brand in the industry of laser drill machines for the aerospace industry
Case
study of an industrial service
brand
This
is a case
study of a
company called Forbes
Facility Services Limited
which adopted a
branding approach and,
in spite of
being a new
company, and in spite of
being in a highly
price sensitive market, showed
good profits and a high level of customer satisfaction.
STEP 1 : HAVE A MARKET INSIGHT : An important step is to really know the different types of customers there are; and to understand their expectations and buying behaviors. After doing this, the company decided to focus on providing housekeeping and cleaning services to industrial companies and plants because it realized that slowly
the market was changing from buying of "products" to buying "services" - because the customers did not want to have the hassle of dealing with multiple vendors like one for the products, the second for product maintenance, the third for supply of labor etc. They wanted to
outsource the whole cleaning job to someone. The market was large and was
estimated at Rs 4000 Crores and it consisted of all types of customers :
offices, shopping malls, guest houses,
factories, airports etc.
STEP 2 : to identify those customers to whom only you can make a
difference but your competitors cannot. These are called as the "target customers". The CEO of this company identified
that the company's offering was demonstrably clear to those customers who had
- large and uninterrupted floor plates (which permit mechanical cleaning )
- situations where the dirt was stickier and more dangerous (which needed trained cleaning workers)
The company introduced a system for its sales force to administer a short questionnaire at the beginning of the sales call to establish if the customer fell in this slot. If not, the sales force was told not to proceed with the call because in that case the company was not sure of making a difference - and when you do not make a difference you do not get a better price. The company
chose to want to sell only to such customers.
STEP 3 : when you are sure about which customers you are going after, it automatically becomes clear (1) what you need to do internally to satisfy them (2) who your competitors are and what you need to do to pr-empt them. The CEO of this company realized that he needs to focus on creating and innovating on two key competencies
- Being good at mechanical cleaning
- Giving a very good training to its front line staff
EFFECTS
OF BRANDING were several. The
first is that the company aimed to go only to those customers who could not be satisfied by
the competition because the floor could not be cleaned effectively by manual
methods and by untrained contractual staff.
The second is that the company’s
business development became more
efficient because they knew which customer to look for and what to tell him.
Third, once the customer was convinced that we were better than the
competition, the price competition became less harsh.
The last I know of, the company was getting paid double than its competitors. Even its method of charging was
different from the competition : competition charged on per person per month
basis and hence their costs were completely visible to the customers. The company charged on per square foot basis and that too proportional to the consumer satisfaction (conformance to the pre-defined level
of service as per Service Level
Agreement). Since the company sold performance, the costs of the company were never really visible to its customers. While competition sold people, the company sold performance. The name spread due to happy customers : virtually every rupee worth of new business emanating from our
existing customers came to the company. Not only that, happy customers liberally gave references and recommendations and brought the cost of new business acquisition down.
BEFORE BRANDING
BECOMES A STORY TO BE TOLD TO OTHERS,
IT MUST COME TO LIFE WITHIN YOUR COMPANY
Branding
is a story that you must tell and practice yourself. Only after the story is assimilated well can
you go out and tell it outside your company. Going back to the example of this company, they not only told the story inside their company but wove it in the training, compensation and promotion of their employees.They created systems for customer satisfaction measurement and put it to use in how they laid out their contracts. They used this understanding to create their organization structure. Many things
became simpler when the branding was understood - for example they realized that
out of so many competitors there was only one who was truly competing with them - this enabled them to evolve competitive strategies.
Brand Building
in Industrial Business
To sum up,
I see the
following rules for
building brand in
a business like
yours
- Invest in studying and knowing the market -
do this periodically because the marker changes
Find the needs, expectations and behavior of different types of customers
- Thoroughly analyze and choose those customers you want to go after
for whom
you can make a difference and be better than your competitors
- Plan to do better than your competitors
on what matters to these chosen customers
and plan to develop your internal competencies accordingly.
Remember you do not need to do better than competition on all counts.
You need to do better only on those things that really matter to your chosen customers.
- Understand who competes with
you for such chosen customers.
You do not need to fear all competitors.
You need to pay attention only to those who may take away your customers.
Or to those whose customers you want to take away.
- Monitor your sales, prices, efforts and also the customer satisfaction.
Use this data to continuously improve.
I hope you noticed that advertising is nowhere in my list of brand building essentials! Please do give your feedback by commenting on this blog. Or call me on 9821046013 or send an e mail to me on skpalekar@hotmail.com